Carnegie Learning - Detailed Review
Education Tools
Carnegie Learning - Detailed Review Contents
Add a header to begin generating the table of contents
Carnegie Learning - Product Overview
Overview of Carnegie Learning
Carnegie Learning is a prominent provider of K-12 education technology, curriculum, and professional learning solutions. Here’s a brief overview of what they offer:Primary Function
Carnegie Learning focuses on creating educational tools that support personalized and adaptive learning. Their products are built to help students learn at their own pace, with a strong emphasis on deep conceptual understanding rather than just memorization or test performance.Target Audience
Carnegie Learning’s products are designed for a variety of educators and students. The primary target audiences include:Tech Savvy Teachers
These are educators aged 25-45, with 3-10 years of teaching experience, who are comfortable using technology in the classroom and are found in urban and suburban areas.Traditional Teachers
Though they may be less tech-inclined, these teachers, aged 45-65 with over 10 years of experience, can still benefit from the support and resources provided by Carnegie Learning.Subject Matter Experts
These are passionate educators with 5-15 years of experience, often found in urban areas with a strong focus on STEM education, who believe in the value of technology to enhance subject matter mastery.Key Features
Carnegie Learning’s products are characterized by several key features:Adaptive Learning
Their tools, such as the Cognitive Tutor, use artificial intelligence to adapt to each student’s learning pace. This tutor monitors students’ actions, provides real-time feedback, and ensures students demonstrate required skills before moving to the next lesson.Comprehensive Assessment Tools
Products like ReadyCheck Assessments and Getting Ready resources help teachers gauge student strengths and anticipate learning needs at the beginning of each module. Summative Assessments and formative evaluations are integrated throughout the lessons to measure student performance continuously.AI-Powered Digital Tools
Tools like MATHia and LiveHint provide AI-powered support. MATHia, for example, offers personalized math instruction, while LiveHint provides real-time hints to help students stay on track.Collaborative Classrooms
Carnegie Learning’s approach fosters collaborative classrooms where teachers are actively engaged with students. This includes innovative programs like MATHstream, a video-based math platform using social media influencers as instructors, which makes learning more vibrant and engaging.Professional Learning Support
The company also offers professional learning services to support educators in effectively using these tools and managing their classrooms. Overall, Carnegie Learning’s products are designed to support teachers in creating a more personalized, engaging, and effective learning environment for their students. Carnegie Learning - User Interface and Experience
Carnegie Learning Overview
Carnegie Learning, a pioneer in AI-driven educational tools, has focused significantly on creating a user-friendly and engaging interface for its products. Here are some key points about the user interface and user experience of their education tools:User Interface
Carnegie Learning’s products are built with a collaborative and vibrant classroom environment in mind. The user interface is modern and updated, a result of CEO Barry Malkin’s initiative to modernize the front-end platform when he took over.Interactive Tools
Their tools, such as ClearMath Elementary and MATHstream, are designed to be highly interactive. For example, MATHstream uses video-based lessons featuring social media influencers as instructors, making the learning experience more engaging and relatable for students.Ease of Use
The interface is designed to be intuitive and easy to use for both educators and students. Carnegie Learning’s products provide additional instructional tools that help educators manage the classroom effectively.AI-Driven Assessments
These tools include AI-driven assessments that offer real-time feedback and guidance, allowing teachers to differentiate instruction among students in a personalized way.Overall User Experience
The overall user experience is centered around personalization and collaboration. The classrooms using Carnegie Learning’s tools are more interactive, with teachers engaged in a collaborative dialogue with students rather than just facilitating from the front of the classroom.Supporting Human Interaction
This approach makes the learning environment more vibrant and interesting for students. Carnegie Learning’s products also ensure that the technology supports human interaction and skills development. For instance, their tools assist educators by providing data and recommending next steps, while also automating routine tasks, which helps in maintaining a balance between AI and human interaction.Conclusion
In summary, Carnegie Learning’s AI-driven education tools offer a user-friendly, modern, and highly interactive interface that supports personalized learning and collaborative classroom environments. The ease of use and overall user experience are optimized to enhance student engagement and learning outcomes. Carnegie Learning - Key Features and Functionality
Carnegie Learning Overview
Carnegie Learning, a pioneer in AI-driven educational tools, offers several key features and functionalities that integrate artificial intelligence to enhance student learning outcomes. Here are the main aspects of their education tools:Collaborative Group Learning
Carnegie Learning’s approach includes a collaborative group learning model where students learn together in a classroom setting. This involves a consumable textbook that allows students to write, sketch, draw, cut, paste, and construct new mathematical ideas. Students build new knowledge based on their prior knowledge and apply math to real-world situations, promoting critical thinking, mathematical reasoning, and learning from peers.Focused Individual Learning
For individual learning, Carnegie Learning provides two main tools:Skills Practice Worksheets
These worksheets are available through the Resource Center and help students practice specific math skills. This focused practice ensures students reinforce their learning outside of the collaborative classroom environment.MATHia Software
MATHia is a 1-to-1 tutoring technology available 24/7 to licensed users. This AI-driven software provides personalized math instruction, adjusting its level of difficulty and content based on the student’s performance and learning needs. MATHia looks beyond just the final answers, analyzing the student’s learning process to provide more effective support.AI Integration
Carnegie Learning’s tools are heavily integrated with AI, particularly in the MATHia software. Here’s how AI works within these tools:Personalized Learning
AI in MATHia allows for personalized instruction, adapting to each student’s learning pace and style. This ensures that each student receives the most relevant and challenging material to help them learn effectively.Real-Time Feedback
The AI technology provides immediate feedback to students, helping them correct mistakes and understand the reasoning behind the correct answers. This real-time feedback is crucial for continuous learning and improvement.Deep Learning Models
Carnegie Learning’s research into AI-driven learning models is backed by significant funding from organizations like the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation and the Walton Family Foundation. These models are developed to ensure that the AI systems can effectively analyze student performance and adjust the learning content accordingly.Professional Learning and Support
Carnegie Learning also offers a range of professional learning resources for educators, including federally-funded programs like the Patterns initiative and The National Institutes, which are recognized as among the top math conferences in the nation. These resources help teachers integrate AI-driven tools into their classrooms effectively and address the growing demand for AI literacy training.Partnership with AI for Education
The recent partnership with AI for Education further enhances Carnegie Learning’s capabilities by providing extensive training in generative AI for educators. This collaboration aims to promote the responsible adoption of AI in K-12 classrooms, addressing the critical need for AI training among teachers and providing practical tools for classroom integration.Conclusion
In summary, Carnegie Learning’s education tools are built on a blend of collaborative and individual learning, supported by AI-driven technologies that provide personalized instruction, real-time feedback, and deep learning models. These features, combined with their professional learning resources and partnerships, make their products highly effective in improving student learning outcomes. Carnegie Learning - Performance and Accuracy
Performance
Carnegie Learning’s partnership with the U.S. Department of Education’s Institute of Education Sciences (IES) and the Center for Applied Special Technology (CAST) has led to a comprehensive study on using AI to support math students with reading disabilities. In this study, the team has successfully demonstrated that human-revised word problems can improve student performance, including for students with disabilities. However, the challenge lies in training generative AI to replicate these human revisions effectively. While AI has shown uneven success in making revisions that lead to improved student outcomes, the research continues to explore ways to integrate AI into the MATHia curriculum.Accuracy
The accuracy of AI-driven revisions in MATHia is still a work in progress. The research has shown that while humans can revise word problems in ways that improve student performance, generative AI has not yet consistently achieved the same level of success. This indicates that while AI has potential, it requires further development to match the accuracy and effectiveness of human revisions.Engagement
MATHia’s AI is designed to provide targeted and individualized support, ensuring that students do not get stuck in repetitive learning loops. This approach helps keep students engaged by offering support that is relevant to their specific needs and learning pace.Limitations and Areas for Improvement
One of the main limitations is the inconsistent performance of generative AI in revising word problems. The team is currently working on a “systematic reading and problem-solving approach” to add instructional support within MATHia, which may help address this issue. Additionally, the integration of AI must be handled carefully to avoid exacerbating existing inequalities in education and ensure that AI-driven tools align with core academic values such as equity and inclusivity.Collaboration and Support
Carnegie Learning’s collaboration with various stakeholders, including specialists in math and reading disabilities, educators, and graduate students, enhances the effectiveness of their tools. For example, their partnership with AI for Education aims to promote AI literacy and support responsible AI use in K-12 education, which can help in the broader adoption and improvement of their AI-driven tools.Conclusion
In summary, Carnegie Learning’s AI-driven tools, such as MATHia, show promise in improving learning outcomes, particularly for students with reading disabilities. However, there are ongoing efforts to improve the accuracy and consistency of AI-generated revisions, and careful consideration is being given to ensure that these tools are used responsibly and equitably. Carnegie Learning - Pricing and Plans
Pricing Structure for Carnegie Learning’s Education Tools
High School Math Solution
Virtual Mathematics Tutoring
Open Educational Resources (OER)
No Tiered Plans
Features and Support
Summary
Carnegie Learning - Integration and Compatibility
Integration with Learning Management Systems (LMS)
Carnegie Learning products are designed to integrate with several major Learning Management Systems. This is achieved through partnerships, such as the one with Edlink, which enables integrations with every major LMS. Here are some of the LMS platforms that Carnegie Learning supports:Schoology
To integrate Carnegie Learning with Schoology, administrators need to use Edlink. This involves connecting Edlink to Schoology using the administrative account, reviewing integration permissions, and installing the Carnegie Learning – Edlink application in the Schoology App Center.Other LMS Platforms
Carnegie Learning also integrates with Blackboard, Canvas, Eduphoria, Google Classroom, ItsLearning, and Moodle. These integrations can be done via Learning Tools Interoperability (LTI), Clever, Classlink, or custom integrations using IMS Global standards and OneRoster.Single Sign-On and User Management
Carnegie Learning supports single sign-on (SSO) through Clever and Classlink, as well as custom LTI and OneRoster integrations. This allows for easy access to the platform without the need for multiple logins. The system also supports managing staff assigned to multiple schools with a single sign-on and allows co-teachers to be assigned to multiple classes.Device and Platform Compatibility
Carnegie Learning’s materials are accessible on various devices, including web-enabled computers and tablets. Students can access the MATHia software and digital eText materials from any of these devices, making it suitable for both in-person and remote learning settings.Digital Materials and Resources
The digital design of Carnegie Learning’s materials replicates the traditional textbook experience. Students can access consumable MATHbook content as a digital eText, and teachers have access to digital teacher guides, presentation slides, and other resources. The platform also includes videos, animations, and simulations to engage students in their learning.Technical Support and Accessibility
Carnegie Learning provides comprehensive technical support, available Monday through Friday from 8:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m. ET. This support includes assistance with installations, networking, and other technical issues, as well as pedagogical and classroom management advice. The materials also conform to the National Instructional Materials Accessibility Standard, ensuring accessibility for all users. In summary, Carnegie Learning’s integration capabilities are extensive, allowing for seamless use with various LMS platforms, devices, and ensuring accessibility and technical support for a smooth educational experience. Carnegie Learning - Customer Support and Resources
Customer Support
For any issues or questions, Carnegie Learning provides multiple avenues for support:
- You can contact their Customer Support Department via phone at 877-401-2527, available Monday through Friday from 8:00 AM to 9:00 PM ET.
- Alternatively, you can reach out via email at help@carnegielearning.com.
Resource Center
The Carnegie Learning Resource Center is a valuable resource for students, parents, and teachers. Here, you can:
- Access digital editions of all student and teacher materials, including textbooks, student assignments, and skills practice worksheets.
- Utilize the “See It, Try It” interactive modules for hands-on learning.
- Find chapter summaries, worked examples, and additional practice materials.
Cognitive Tutor Software
Carnegie Learning’s Cognitive Tutor Software is an adaptive AI-driven tool that individualizes mathematics instruction based on each student’s learning needs. The software includes engagement features like interest areas, characters, and personalization options to keep students engaged. Users can access the Cognitive Tutor Software through the Resource Center, using a school ID, username, and password provided by the teacher.
Online Resources
The Resource Center also includes a “Home Connection” section with links to general math websites, providing additional learning resources outside of the core materials.
Registration and Access
To access the Resource Center, students need to register using a valid email address and a Student Access Code provided by their teacher. The registration process is straightforward and takes only a few minutes.
Support Documentation
For help with registration, using the software or textbooks, or any other issues, the Resource Center has a ‘Support’ page with helpful documents and interactive tutorials. Users can also change their account preferences through the ‘Your Account’ page.
By providing these comprehensive support options and resources, Carnegie Learning ensures that users can effectively utilize their AI-driven education tools and achieve their learning goals.
Carnegie Learning - Pros and Cons
Advantages of Carnegie Learning
Collaborative Learning Environment
Carnegie Learning fosters a collaborative and engaging learning environment. Their approach encourages students to build on their prior knowledge and real-world experiences, promoting active participation and confidence in mathematical abilities.
Research-Backed Instructional Approach
The instructional method is grounded in cognitive and learning science, developed by researchers, instructional designers, and master practitioners. This approach includes key components such as ENGAGE, DEVELOP, and DEMONSTRATE, which ensure a comprehensive learning experience.
AI-Driven Solutions
Carnegie Learning has over 26 years of experience in developing AI-driven educational tools. Their partnership with AI for Education aims to promote AI literacy and support responsible AI use in K-12 education, providing practical tools and training for educators.
Extensive Reach and Funding
Carnegie Learning’s solutions are used by over 5.5 million students in K-12 schools across North America. The company has received significant funding from organizations like the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation and the Walton Family Foundation, supporting their research and development.
Support for Special Populations
Carnegie Learning’s approach is designed to support students of special populations by ensuring they feel supported and confident in their abilities. This strengths-based approach helps in fostering true collaborative learning.
Disadvantages of Carnegie Learning
Teacher Preparation and Support
There have been concerns raised about the lack of adequate preparation and support for teachers using Carnegie Learning’s curriculum. Teachers have reported being given the curriculum with little to no advice on how to teach it, leading to difficulties in implementation.
Student Confusion and Performance
Some students and teachers have reported that the Carnegie Learning curriculum can be confusing and does not provide a clear lesson structure. This has led to poor performance in tests, with significant numbers of students failing, especially when tests are weighted heavily in the grading system.
Dependence on Technology
The reliance on tools like MATHia, while helpful for some, can sometimes lead to a lack of real mathematical practice. Students may find the activities too simplistic or reliant on technology rather than actual mathematical skills.
Assessment and Grading Issues
The assessment and grading system associated with Carnegie Learning has been criticized. The limited number of tests and the high weightage given to these tests can be stressful and unfair to students, especially if they are not allowed to retake tests even with lower scores.
In summary, while Carnegie Learning offers a collaborative, research-backed, and AI-driven educational approach, it faces challenges related to teacher preparation, student confusion, and assessment methodologies. Addressing these issues could enhance the overall effectiveness of their educational tools.
Carnegie Learning - Comparison with Competitors
When comparing Carnegie Learning to other AI-driven education tools, several key features and alternatives stand out:
Unique Features of Carnegie Learning
Carnegie Learning is renowned for its AI-powered math education software that provides personalized learning experiences. Here are some of its unique features:Adaptive Lessons
Carnegie Learning uses machine learning algorithms to offer interactive lessons and real-time feedback, helping students grasp difficult math concepts.Customizable Courses
Educators can customize courses to fit the needs of their students, and the platform allows for real-time tracking of student progress.Engaging Environment
The platform is designed to keep students motivated and engaged through adaptive and interactive lessons.Competitors and Alternatives
Woot Math
Woot Math is another AI-powered math education platform that provides personalized learning experiences similar to Carnegie Learning. It uses artificial intelligence to personalize math lessons and offers real-time feedback and support to help students improve their math skills.IXL
IXL offers personalized learning across a comprehensive K-12 curriculum, including math, English language arts, and science. It provides real-time analysis and personalized guidance, making it a strong alternative for those seeking broader curriculum coverage.Querium
Querium is an AI-powered tutoring platform that assesses students’ strengths and weaknesses, providing targeted instruction and real-time feedback. This platform is particularly useful for students needing personalized tutoring in various subjects.Smart Sparrow
Smart Sparrow is an adaptive e-learning platform that uses AI to personalize learning and provide real-time feedback. It allows students to learn at their own pace and achieve their full potential, making it a viable alternative for adaptive learning needs.Additional Features to Consider
Gradescope
While not a direct alternative for math education, Gradescope is an AI-powered grading tool that streamlines the grading process for multiple-choice, fill-in-the-blank, and coding questions. It provides instant feedback and tracks student progress, which can be beneficial in conjunction with Carnegie Learning.Tutor.ai
Tutor.ai is an AI-based tutoring platform that connects students with qualified tutors for virtual tutoring sessions. This can complement Carnegie Learning by providing additional support in subjects where students need one-on-one assistance.MagicSchool
MagicSchool offers a suite of 50 AI tools for teachers, including features for lesson planning, report writing, personalized assessments, and social-emotional learning. While it is more focused on teacher support, it can be used in conjunction with Carnegie Learning to enhance the overall educational experience. In summary, Carnegie Learning stands out with its adaptive and interactive math lessons, but alternatives like Woot Math, IXL, Querium, and Smart Sparrow offer similar or complementary functionalities that can cater to different educational needs. Carnegie Learning - Frequently Asked Questions
Frequently Asked Questions about Carnegie Learning
What is Carnegie Learning and its history?
Carnegie Learning is an innovative education technology and curriculum solutions provider for K-12 education. Founded within Carnegie Mellon University, the company has over 26 years of experience in developing AI-driven educational tools. It has grown to become a leading edtech company, with its solutions used by over 5.5 million students in K-12 schools across North America.What subjects and areas does Carnegie Learning cover?
Carnegie Learning offers a wide range of solutions covering math, literacy and English Language Arts (ELA), and world languages. Their products include CLEAR Math, CLEAR Literacy, and CLEAR Languages, among others. They also provide professional learning services and various other educational tools such as MATHia, Fast ForWord, and more.How does Carnegie Learning use AI in its educational tools?
Carnegie Learning integrates AI into its educational tools to enhance student learning outcomes. For example, their Cognitive Tutor software uses AI to provide personalized math instruction, and their CLEAR solutions utilize AI to create collaborative and independent learning experiences. Recently, they have partnered with AI for Education to promote AI literacy and support the responsible use of AI in K-12 classrooms.What is the partnership between Carnegie Learning and AI for Education?
The partnership between Carnegie Learning and AI for Education aims to accelerate AI literacy training and promote the responsible adoption of artificial intelligence in K-12 classrooms. This collaboration combines Carnegie Learning’s expertise in AI-driven educational tools with AI for Education’s focus on training educators in generative AI. The goal is to empower more educators with the skills and knowledge to effectively use AI in their classrooms.How has Carnegie Learning improved its sales and customer service processes?
Carnegie Learning has streamlined its sales and customer service processes by implementing Salesforce AI. This has led to increased productivity, deeper customer relationships, and a significant sevenfold increase in revenue. The AI-driven tools help sales representatives optimize their daily operations, provide personalized customer experiences, and reduce manual tasks such as pricing and quoting.What kind of support and training does Carnegie Learning offer to educators?
Carnegie Learning provides extensive support and training for educators through its professional learning services. This includes programs like Patterns Professional Learning, Instructional Services, and District Impact Services. Additionally, their partnership with AI for Education includes training educators in generative AI, ensuring they have the necessary skills to integrate AI effectively into their classrooms.How much does Carnegie Learning’s educational software and materials cost?
The costs of Carnegie Learning’s products can vary. For example, as of 2009-2010, the Curriculum Kit for Algebra I was priced at $99, with other components like Teacher Text Sets and Student Text Sets available at different prices. Volume discounts are available for school districts, and the annualized cost per student includes fees for licenses, teacher training, and other support.What research and funding support Carnegie Learning’s AI-driven learning models?
Carnegie Learning’s research into AI-driven learning models is backed by significant funding from various organizations, including the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation and the Walton Family Foundation. This funding has supported the development of their award-winning math, literacy, and world language solutions.How many educators and students are impacted by Carnegie Learning’s solutions?
Carnegie Learning’s solutions are used by over 5.5 million students in K-12 schools across North America. Additionally, AI for Education, their partner, has already trained over 250,000 educators globally and works with large school districts across the U.S.What are some specific products offered by Carnegie Learning?
Some specific products include MATHia for math education, Fast ForWord for literacy, and various world language programs such as ¡Qué chévere!: Spanish and Deutsch So Aktuell 8e: German. They also offer literacy solutions like Lenses on Literature and Mirrors & Windows.How does Carnegie Learning ensure the responsible use of AI in classrooms?
Carnegie Learning, in partnership with AI for Education, focuses on providing AI literacy training and ensuring educators have the knowledge and support needed to use AI effectively and ethically in their classrooms. This includes resources and guidance to support responsible AI use and the development of classroom policies for AI integration.