Keybase - Detailed Review
Privacy Tools
Keybase - Detailed Review Contents
Add a header to begin generating the table of contents
Keybase - Product Overview
Keybase Overview
Keybase is a secure communication and collaboration platform that focuses on end-to-end encryption and public-key cryptography. Here’s a brief overview of its primary function, target audience, and key features:Primary Function
Keybase’s central function is to store and manage public signatures and keys in a standardized format. This includes identity proofs, follower statements, key ownership, and revocations. For example, users can link their social media accounts (like Twitter or GitHub) to their Keybase account, ensuring that outside observers can verify the authenticity of these connections through signed statements.Target Audience
Keybase is intended for two main groups:Non-Technical Users
Individuals who rely on the internet for daily tasks and are concerned about security and privacy.Technical Early Adopters
Users who are familiar with public-key cryptography but may not know how Keybase simplifies these processes.Key Features
End-to-End Encryption
Keybase provides end-to-end encryption for messages and files, ensuring that only the sender and the intended recipient can read the content. This is particularly useful for secure communication and file sharing, especially in comparison to other chat tools that may allow service providers to read messages.Identity Proofs and Key Management
Users can establish and verify identities across different platforms (e.g., Twitter, GitHub) through signed statements. This helps in building a web of trust where users can confidently identify and communicate with each other.File and Message Encryption, Signing, and Verification
Keybase allows users to encrypt, decrypt, sign, and verify messages and files. Encrypted files are saved in the Saltpack format, which can be shared or stored securely anywhere. Signing messages or files ensures that the recipient knows the sender’s identity and that the content has not been tampered with.Multi-Platform Support
Keybase supports various platforms, including Twitter, Facebook, GitHub, Reddit, and Hacker News, making it easy to encrypt messages or files for users on these platforms.Open Source and Security
Keybase is open source, which means its code is publicly viewable. Following a security audit in 2019, the team has enhanced the security features, making it a reliable tool for secure collaboration.Conclusion
In summary, Keybase is a powerful tool for secure communication, file sharing, and identity verification, making it accessible and beneficial for both non-technical users and technical enthusiasts alike. Keybase - User Interface and Experience
User Interface and Experience
The user interface and experience of Keybase are designed to be user-friendly and secure, even for those who are not deeply familiar with encryption and security tools.Installation and Setup
To get started with Keybase, users can download the application from the Keybase website or from app stores for mobile devices. The installation process is straightforward: users create an account, choose a username (which cannot be changed later), and optionally add a phone number and email address. Each device is given a unique name that is publicly visible, which helps in managing multiple devices associated with the same account.User Interface
The Keybase application has a clean and intuitive interface. It includes several key features such as the Chat tab, Teams tab, and Files tab. The Chat tab allows users to start new conversations with other Keybase users by searching for their usernames. The Teams tab enables the creation of group chats and team folders, where users can be assigned different roles (Readers, Writers, Admins, and Owners) to manage access and control.Ease of Use
Keybase is intended to be easy to use, even for those without extensive technical knowledge. The application simplifies the process of sharing files and having secure conversations through end-to-end encryption. This means that only the sender and the recipient can read the messages and files exchanged. The interface guides users through the process of setting up and using the various features without requiring a deep understanding of cryptographic concepts.Key Features
Chat
Keybase Chat allows users to send messages to others using their online aliases, such as Twitter or Reddit accounts, even if the recipient is not yet a Keybase user. Messages can be set to automatically delete after a specified duration.Teams
Users can create teams with different roles for members, facilitating secure group communication and file sharing.Files
Keybase offers a secure file storage system with private, public, and team folders. Files can be synced across devices, but users are advised to be cautious when syncing files from untrusted sources.Security and Privacy
Keybase emphasizes security and privacy. The application uses client-side encryption, and data is transferred using industry-standard TLS. The service collects minimal personal information and does not track users across third-party websites. Keybase also supports two-factor authentication and has strict internal security measures to protect user data.Overall User Experience
The overall user experience of Keybase is focused on simplicity and security. The application is open-source, which adds to its transparency and trustworthiness. While it may have some usability issues, particularly for advanced users familiar with other encryption tools, Keybase generally provides a straightforward and secure way to communicate and share files online. Keybase - Key Features and Functionality
Keybase Overview
Keybase is a comprehensive secure messaging and file-sharing service that offers several key features, each designed to enhance privacy and security.End-to-End Encryption
Keybase applies end-to-end encryption to all messages and files using algorithms such as XSalsa20, Poly1305, Ed25519, and SHA512. This ensures that only the sender and the intended recipient can read the content, making it secure against interception by third parties, including Keybase itself.Secure Messaging and File Sharing
Keybase allows users to send encrypted messages and share files securely. Users can encrypt messages or files for specific recipients using their public keys, and these can be shared via various platforms like Twitter, Facebook, GitHub, or directly within Keybase. The encrypted files are saved in the Saltpack format, ensuring they remain secure even when stored or shared outside of Keybase.Self-Destructing Messages
Keybase offers the feature of self-destructing or “exploding” messages, which can be set to delete after a specified period. This adds an extra layer of security for sensitive information.Multi-Device Support
Users can be logged in on multiple devices simultaneously, making it convenient to stay connected across different platforms. This includes clients for Android, iOS, Mac OS, Windows, Linux, and browser extensions.Cloud Storage
Keybase provides 250GB of free, encrypted cloud storage per user. This storage is not a file sync solution but rather a secure place to store files, which can be accessed from any device linked to the user’s account.Online Identity Verification
Keybase allows users to securely store and share identity documents. This feature enables users to verify their identities and share them as needed with just a few clicks.Public and Private Teams
Users can create public or private teams for personal or business use. All communications and team data within these teams are end-to-end encrypted, ensuring secure collaboration.Encrypted Git Repositories
Keybase supports encrypted Git repositories, allowing users to securely track changes in code or other documents. This feature is particularly useful for developers who need to collaborate on projects while maintaining security.Stellar Wallet
Keybase includes a secure wallet for the Stellar Lumens cryptocurrency, providing a safe way to manage digital assets.Bots and Automation
Users can create their own Keybase bots or use pre-built ones to add functionality to their Keybase activities. This can automate various tasks and enhance the user experience.Signing and Verifying Messages
Keybase allows users to sign messages or files using their private keys, ensuring that the recipient can verify the authenticity of the sender and that the content has not been tampered with. This feature is crucial for maintaining the integrity of the data being shared.Blockchain-Based Security
Keybase uses blockchain technology to protect against tampering and ensure the integrity of the data stored on its platform. This adds an additional layer of security to the already encrypted data.AI Integration
While the primary features of Keybase are centered around encryption and security, there is no explicit mention of AI integration in the available resources. Keybase’s security and functionality are largely based on cryptographic techniques and user authentication methods rather than AI-driven technologies.Ownership and Privacy Concerns
It’s important to note that Keybase was acquired by Zoom in 2020, which has raised privacy concerns due to Zoom’s past practices and ties to China. This acquisition has led some to question the continued privacy and security of using Keybase.Conclusion
In summary, Keybase offers a robust set of features focused on secure communication and file sharing, leveraging strong encryption and blockchain technology to protect user data. However, the recent ownership change has introduced new privacy concerns that users should be aware of. Keybase - Performance and Accuracy
Evaluating Keybase’s Performance and Accuracy
Evaluating the performance and accuracy of Keybase in the context of privacy tools involves several key aspects:
Security and Encryption
Keybase is highly regarded for its strong security features. It uses end-to-end encryption for all messages and files, employing algorithms such as XSalsa20, Poly1305, Ed25519, and SHA512. This ensures that data remains private and protected from unauthorized access.
Audit and Vulnerabilities
A security review by NCC Group in 2018 highlighted that while Keybase’s design is secure against many types of attacks, there were some weaknesses in the implementation. However, these issues were quickly addressed and fixed by the time of the report’s publication in 2019. The review also noted that the complexity of the codebase and the presence of legacy code posed some challenges, but these did not necessarily imply security vulnerabilities.
Documentation and Auditability
One of the significant areas for improvement is the documentation of Keybase’s protocols. The NCC Group report emphasized that better documentation is crucial for independent implementations and for verifying the integrity of the data. Some features, especially legacy ones, lack detailed documentation, which complicates the auditing process and increases the difficulty of verifying both the data and the client code.
User Experience and Usability
Keybase has been criticized for its usability, particularly for users who are not familiar with cryptography and encryption technologies. The interface, while improved, can still be confusing, especially since Keybase maintains a separate keyring from other tools like GPG. This can lead to learning curves and potential mistakes for users who are accustomed to other cryptographic tools.
Data Collection and Privacy
While Keybase excels in encrypting user data, it does collect a significant amount of non-encrypted information, including names, email addresses, social media handles, and device details. This data collection, combined with the service being based in the United States where government surveillance is a concern, raises privacy issues for some users.
Ownership and Trust
A recent development that affects trust in Keybase is its acquisition by Zoom, a company with ties to China and a history of privacy concerns. This change in ownership has led some to question the continued privacy and security of the service.
Additional Features and Performance
Keybase offers a range of features beyond secure messaging, including secure file sharing, online identity verification, encrypted Git repositories, and a Stellar Lumens cryptocurrency wallet. The service also provides 250GB of free, encrypted cloud storage per user. However, the support for these features is sometimes lacking, with users noting that updates can take a long time and that there is no comprehensive support section for basic user questions.
Conclusion
In summary, Keybase performs well in terms of security and encryption, but it has areas for improvement such as better documentation, enhanced usability, and addressing privacy concerns related to data collection and ownership. Ensuring that these aspects are addressed can further strengthen the trust and accuracy of the service.
Keybase - Pricing and Plans
Pricing Structure of Keybase
Free Plan
Keybase currently offers all its services completely free of charge. There are no costs associated with using the platform, and the company has stated that they will never run ads on Keybase or sell user data.Features Available
Despite being free, Keybase provides a wide range of features, including:- End-to-end (E2E) PGP encryption for messaging and file sharing
- Secure file-sharing with 250GB of free cloud storage per user
- Online identity verification
- Public and private teams with Slack-style communication
- Encrypted Git repositories
- A secure wallet for the Stellar Lumens cryptocurrency
- Self-destructing (exploding) messages
- Multi-device support
- Blockchain-based protection against tampering
Future Paid Options
While the core product remains free, Keybase has mentioned plans to introduce optional paid features in the future, primarily aimed at corporate teams. Additionally, they may offer paid storage options for users who need more than the 250GB of free storage provided.No Tiered Plans
As of now, there are no tiered plans or different pricing tiers available on Keybase. The service is uniformly free for all users, with the same set of features and benefits.Summary
In summary, Keybase offers a comprehensive set of secure messaging and file-sharing features entirely free, with no current tiered plans or additional costs. Keybase - Integration and Compatibility
Integration with Other Tools
Keybase allows users to connect their social media identities, such as Twitter, GitHub, Reddit, and Hacker News accounts, to their encryption keys. This integration is achieved through a process called “identity proofs,” where users sign a statement with their private key and post it on the respective social media platform. This method ensures that the link between the online identity and the encryption key is publicly verifiable. For key management, Keybase can be integrated with tools like OpenBao, which uses OpenPGP-compatible programs. OpenBao can initialize and manage unseal keys using Keybase, where the keys are encrypted with the users’ public PGP keys obtained from Keybase. This integration enhances the security of key distribution and management.Compatibility Across Platforms
Keybase supports a wide range of platforms, including:Desktop Operating Systems
Keybase has client applications for Windows, Mac OS, and Linux. The installation process varies slightly depending on the operating system, with Linux installations requiring terminal commands.Mobile Devices
Keybase offers mobile apps for Android and iOS, available through their respective app stores. Mobile devices need to be authorized using another device or a paper key for security reasons.Web Interface
Keybase also provides a web interface that allows users to access many of its features, including encrypted chat and file storage, directly from a browser.Device Authorization and Multi-Device Support
Keybase ensures security by requiring device authorization. When setting up a new device, users must authorize it using another device or a paper key. This feature allows users to be online with multiple devices simultaneously, enhancing convenience and connectivity.Additional Features and Compatibility
Keybase offers several additional features that integrate well with its core functionality:Encrypted Chat and File Sharing
Keybase provides end-to-end encrypted chat and file-sharing capabilities, which can be accessed across all supported platforms.Teams and Group Communications
Users can create public or private teams for secure, Slack-style communications. These teams support end-to-end encryption for all communications and data.Encrypted Git Repositories
Keybase supports encrypted Git repositories, allowing users to securely track changes in code or documents.Cryptocurrency Wallets
Keybase includes a secure wallet for Stellar Lumens, integrating cryptocurrency management into its platform. Overall, Keybase’s integration with various tools and its compatibility across multiple platforms make it a comprehensive solution for secure communication, file sharing, and key management. Keybase - Customer Support and Resources
Customer Support
Keybase does not have a traditional customer support system like many other services, but it provides several ways to get help and resolve issues:Community and Documentation
Keybase offers extensive documentation and guides that can be found in the resources section. This resource covers various aspects of using Keybase, including setting up an account, creating teams, and managing files.Public Forums and Discussions
Users can engage with the Keybase community through public forums and discussions. This can be a valuable resource for troubleshooting and getting tips from other users.GitHub and Open Source
Since Keybase is open source, users can also contribute to or seek help from the community on GitHub. This allows for collaborative problem-solving and feedback.Additional Resources
User Guides and Tutorials
The user guides and the beginner’s guide from the Freedom of the Press Foundation provide step-by-step instructions on how to get started with Keybase, including setting up accounts, creating teams, and managing files.File Management and Sharing
Keybase allows users to store and share files securely through private, public, and team folders. This is detailed in the user guides and the beginner’s guide.Chat and Team Features
Users can start conversations, create teams, and manage team roles. The user guides and the beginner’s guide explain how to use these features effectively.Privacy and Security
Keybase emphasizes strong privacy and security measures. The platform uses public-key cryptography to ensure that only intended recipients can access shared data. More information on this can be found in the resources section.Privacy and Security Tools
Keybase is built with strong privacy and security in mind:Public-Key Cryptography
Ensures that your data is secure and only accessible by intended recipients.Automatic Message Deletion
Users can set messages to automatically delete after a specified duration, enhancing privacy.Blocking and Reporting
Users can block and report other users to control who can interact with them on the platform. While Keybase does not offer traditional customer support like phone numbers or email support specifically for its privacy tools, the comprehensive documentation and community resources make it easier for users to find help and use the platform securely. Keybase - Pros and Cons
Advantages of Keybase
Keybase offers several significant advantages, particularly in the areas of security, privacy, and multi-functional utility.Security and Privacy
- Keybase uses public-key cryptography, ensuring that your data is end-to-end encrypted. This means only you and your intended recipients can access the information you share, and not even Keybase can access it.
- Your private keys are stored only on your devices, not on Keybase’s servers, adding an extra layer of security against potential server hacks.
- The platform employs 256-bit encryption, making it virtually impossible for unauthorized parties to decrypt your data.
Multi-functional Utility
- Keybase serves as an all-in-one platform for team collaboration, similar to Slack, with features like chat, sub-teams, and channels.
- It offers cloud storage with up to 250GB of free space, categorized into public, private, and team files.
- Keybase includes a fully encrypted git version control system, which is more secure than other git hosting services.
- The platform allows you to host simple websites in the public folder, accessible via a custom domain name (e.g., `yourusername.keybase.pub`).
- Keybase also integrates a cryptocurrency wallet for Stellar Lumens and other popular cryptocurrencies.
Identity Verification and Management
- Keybase helps you map your identity to your public keys and vice versa, providing a way to prove your social media identities through the platform.
User Control
- You have full control over who can interact with you on Keybase, with features to block and report users, and restrict who can chat with you or add you to a team.
Disadvantages of Keybase
While Keybase offers many benefits, there are also some notable drawbacks to consider.Potential Risks with Private Key Material
- There is a concern about the handling of private key material. Keybase allows uploading private key material to their servers, which, although encrypted, could still pose risks if a determined attacker gains access to both the encrypted keys and the passphrases.
Technical Issues and User Experience
- Some users have reported that the application can be buggy, particularly after system updates, leading to issues like lag, unresponsiveness, and black screens on mobile devices.
- The platform can be intimidating for those unfamiliar with cryptography and encryption technologies, requiring time to get used to its features and functionalities.
Limitations and Connectivity Issues
- There have been reports of connection issues that can make the platform unusable at times. Additionally, the cloud storage is not currently expandable, although this is planned for the future.
Public Information Visibility
- Since Keybase uses public-key cryptography, some of your information (like your username, device names, public key, followers, and social media proofs) is publicly visible by default.
Keybase - Comparison with Competitors
When comparing Keybase to other privacy tools in the AI-driven product category, several key features and differences stand out.
Keybase Unique Features
- End-to-End Encryption: Keybase uses end-to-end encryption for both messaging and file sharing, ensuring that only the sender and the intended recipient can access the content. This encryption is based on algorithms like XSalsa20, Poly1305, Ed25519, and SHA512.
- File Sharing and Storage: Keybase offers 250 GB of free, encrypted cloud storage per user, with the ability to store and share files in private, public, or team folders. Files are automatically encrypted and signed by the user’s private key.
- Identity Verification and Teams: Keybase allows for secure identity verification and the creation of public or private teams, all with end-to-end encrypted communications and data.
- Blockchain Integration: Keybase uses blockchain technology to protect against tampering and ensure the integrity of the data.
Potential Alternatives and Comparisons
Securiti AI
- Comprehensive Privacy and Security: Securiti AI offers a more comprehensive suite that combines privacy and security management. It includes features like automated sensitive data discovery, AI-powered risk assessments, consent management, and zero-trust access controls. While it is more complex to implement and has higher licensing costs, it provides a unified solution for data privacy, security, and compliance.
- Automation and Governance: Unlike Keybase, Securiti AI focuses heavily on automating compliance tasks and providing real-time visibility into data usage patterns, making it ideal for businesses with stringent regulatory requirements.
Element
- Decentralized and End-to-End Encrypted: Element, built on the Matrix protocol, offers a decentralized and end-to-end encrypted communication platform. It provides complete ownership of data and can be deployed on-premise or in a secure cloud environment. While it does not offer the same level of file storage as Keybase, it is highly regarded for its flexibility, federation, and data sovereignty.
Other Alternatives
- Rocket.Chat: This platform focuses more on real-time communications and does not offer the same level of encryption or file storage as Keybase. However, it is a viable alternative for teams needing secure communication without the need for extensive file sharing.
- Keet: Keet provides encrypted video calls and file sharing but lacks the comprehensive file storage and team management features of Keybase. It is more suited for peer-to-peer communications rather than team or organizational use.
Considerations
- Ownership and Privacy Concerns: Keybase, now owned by Zoom, raises privacy concerns due to Zoom’s past practices. This might be a significant factor for users prioritizing privacy and security.
- User Experience: Keybase can be complicated to install and configure, and its chat functionality is not as user-friendly as some competitors. In contrast, alternatives like Element and Securiti AI may offer more streamlined experiences for specific use cases.
Keybase - Frequently Asked Questions
Frequently Asked Questions about Keybase
Q: How does Keybase ensure my data privacy?
Keybase ensures your data privacy through public-key cryptography, which means only your intended recipients can access what you share and store. Keybase itself cannot access your data, and it does not sell or rent your data for any reason. Your data is end-to-end encrypted, so only you and the people you share it with can read it.Q: What information is publicly visible on Keybase?
On Keybase, some of your information is publicly visible due to the use of public-key cryptography. This includes your username, device names, public key, followers and who you follow, social accounts used as proofs (e.g., Twitter, GitHub, Reddit), and any other details you choose to share on your profile.Q: How does Keybase secure my account and data?
Your Keybase account is protected by public-key cryptography, where your devices are cryptographically linked to your account. This ensures that only you can access your account. All data you store or share on Keybase is end-to-end encrypted using 256-bit encryption, which is highly secure. Your private keys are stored only on your devices and not on Keybase’s servers.Q: Can I control who interacts with me on Keybase?
Yes, you have control over who can interact with you on Keybase. You can block and report people on an individual basis, restrict who can chat with you or add you to a team, and even block entire conversations or teams. When you block someone, they can no longer interact with you, although they may still follow you.Q: How does Keybase use the Bitcoin blockchain for security?
Keybase uses the Bitcoin blockchain to ensure the integrity and consistency of user data. By encoding data in the Bitcoin blockchain, Keybase creates an immutable and public record. This prevents attacks such as modifying or tampering with user data, as any changes would be detectable due to the blockchain’s properties.Q: What happens if Keybase’s servers are compromised?
Even if Keybase’s servers are compromised, the security of your account and data is not at risk. This is because your private keys are only stored on your devices and not on Keybase’s servers. The end-to-end encryption ensures that only you and your intended recipients can access your data.Q: Can Keybase reset or replace my keys without my knowledge?
Keybase’s design prevents the server from resetting or replacing your keys without detection. If a server tries to roll back your key chain or use a disclosed key, this can be detected by frequently verifying your key chain against the one committed to the Bitcoin blockchain and through follower statements.Q: How does Keybase handle local key security on my devices?
Keybase uses Local Key Security (LKS) to protect your private keys on your devices. LKS ensures that your private keys are encrypted and can only be unlocked with your Keybase password. This protection is maintained even in environments without native key-protection facilities.Q: Is Keybase free to use?
Yes, Keybase is free to use for individual accounts. While Keybase may charge for special features for larger corporations in the future, existing and individual accounts will always remain free. Additionally, Keybase does not rely on ads for revenue.Q: Who owns Keybase now?
Keybase was acquired by Zoom in May 2020. This acquisition is part of Zoom’s efforts to enhance its security measures, including building an end-to-end encryption service.