Microsoft Identity Manager - Detailed Review
Security Tools
Microsoft Identity Manager - Product Overview
Introduction to Microsoft Identity Manager (MIM)
Microsoft Identity Manager (MIM) is an on-premises tool designed to manage access, users, policies, and credentials within an organization. Here’s a brief overview of its primary function, target audience, and key features:
Primary Function
MIM is used to centralize the management of user accounts and identities across various systems. It synchronizes user identity data between different systems, ensuring consistent identity lifecycle management. This includes synchronizing Active Directory (AD) with multiple external systems, enabling a unified approach to identity and access management.
Target Audience
MIM is primarily targeted at enterprise security and systems administrators responsible for managing identity and access within large organizations. The majority of its customers are companies with 10,000 employees, although it is also used by organizations with 1,000 to 9,999 employees.
Key Features
- Identity Management: MIM handles user on- and offboarding, attribute synchronization, and self-service profile management. It ensures that the correct users have the appropriate access rights across different systems.
- Group Management: This includes manual, manager-based, and dynamic groups, along with self-service workflows and access request and approval processes.
- Credential Management: MIM offers self-service functionalities, multi-factor authentication (MFA), and password synchronization to manage credentials effectively.
- Policy Management: It covers authentication, authorization, codeless provisioning, and a SharePoint-based admin portal for policy management.
- Synchronization Service: MIM includes a synchronization engine that helps in synchronizing user identity data between different systems, ensuring consistency across the organization.
- Reporting and Privileged Access Management (PAM): These components help in monitoring and managing access rights, especially for privileged accounts.
Additional Components
MIM consists of various components such as the MIM Service, Synchronization Service database, Reporting, Privileged Access Management (PAM), and MIM client add-ins. These components work together to support a wide range of identity management features.
In summary, Microsoft Identity Manager is a comprehensive on-premises solution for managing identities, access, and policies, particularly suited for large and complex enterprise environments.
Microsoft Identity Manager - User Interface and Experience
User Interface
The user interface of Microsoft Identity Manager (MIM) is often described as complex and challenging to use. Users and administrators have reported that the interface can be frustrating, with a steep learning curve. This complexity can make it difficult for new users to adapt quickly, as the system requires a significant amount of time and effort to become familiar with its various components and functionalities.
Ease of Use
MIM’s ease of use is a point of contention. While it offers a wide range of features and capabilities, the complexity of the interface can hinder user adoption and productivity. The system is not as intuitive or user-friendly as some of its modern counterparts, which can lead to increased administrative overhead and frustration among users.
Overall User Experience
The overall user experience with MIM is influenced by its legacy design, which was primarily focused on on-premises environments. Although it can be extended to support cloud-based environments through integrations like Azure AD Connect, it lacks the cloud-first approach that many modern identity management solutions offer. This can make managing hybrid environments more challenging and less flexible compared to more contemporary solutions.
Conclusion
In summary, while MIM is a powerful tool for managing identities and access, its user interface and overall user experience are areas that could be improved. For organizations seeking a more streamlined, intuitive, and user-friendly identity management solution, considering a modern alternative might be beneficial.
Microsoft Identity Manager - Key Features and Functionality
Microsoft Identity Manager (MIM)
MIM is a comprehensive on-premises tool designed to manage identities, access, and credentials within an organization. Here are the main features and functionalities of MIM, along with their benefits:
Identity Management
MIM enables the synchronization of user accounts across multiple systems, including Active Directory (AD) and other external directories. This feature ensures that user identities are consistent and up-to-date across all systems. It includes user onboarding, offboarding, attribute synchronization, and self-service profile management. This centralization simplifies identity lifecycle management and ensures that users have the correct access rights.
Group Management
MIM facilitates the management of groups, including manual, manager-based, and dynamic groups. It features self-service workflows for group membership, access requests, and approval processes. This helps in automating group management tasks and ensures that group memberships are accurate and current.
Credential Management
The credential management feature in MIM includes self-service functionalities for password reset, multi-factor authentication (MFA), and password synchronization. This enhances security by ensuring strong authentication practices and reduces the administrative burden of password management.
Policy Management
MIM covers various aspects of policy management, such as authentication, authorization, codeless provisioning, and a SharePoint-based admin portal. It allows for the definition of rules and policies that govern user access and identity management, ensuring compliance with organizational and regulatory requirements.
Role-Based Access Control (RBAC) and Privileged Access Management (PAM)
MIM supports RBAC through its integration with BHOLD, which helps in managing access based on roles. Additionally, it includes PAM features to manage and monitor privileged accounts, ensuring that sensitive access is tightly controlled and audited.
Reporting and Compliance
MIM provides reporting capabilities that help organizations meet audit and compliance requirements. It generates reports on user activities, access changes, and other identity-related events, which is crucial for maintaining regulatory compliance and internal security policies.
Custom Workflows and Connectors
MIM allows organizations to build custom workflows and connectors to integrate with internal systems, such as CISCO Unified Communications Manager. This flexibility enables the automation of complex user processes and the synchronization of data across various applications.
AI Integration
While MIM itself does not inherently integrate AI, the broader Microsoft ecosystem, particularly with the introduction of Microsoft Entra, is where AI starts to play a role. For example, Microsoft Entra includes features like Security Copilot, which can help automate common tasks, troubleshoot identity scenarios, and provide risk summaries and remediation steps. However, these AI-driven features are more aligned with Microsoft Entra rather than being a part of MIM directly.
Conclusion
In summary, MIM is a powerful tool for managing identities and access within on-premises environments, offering a wide range of features that simplify and secure identity lifecycle management. While it does not include AI integration itself, the transition to cloud-based solutions like Azure AD and Microsoft Entra brings AI capabilities into the broader identity management landscape.
Microsoft Identity Manager - Performance and Accuracy
Performance
MIM is a comprehensive identity and access management solution that has been widely used for managing identities across various environments. Here are some performance aspects:Resource Requirements
For optimal performance, MIM requires significant resources. For instance, it is recommended to have at least 16 CPU cores on the SQL servers, and a network connection of at least 1 Gbit between the MIM servers and SQL servers to avoid performance degradation.Synchronization
MIM’s synchronization service is critical for maintaining accurate and up-to-date identity information. However, there are specific settings and configurations that need to be followed to avoid issues, such as using the “SharePoint Active Directory Import” option instead of the MIM Synchronization service for certain scenarios.Accuracy
Accuracy in MIM is largely dependent on proper configuration and maintenance:Data Integrity
MIM ensures data integrity by synchronizing identity data across different systems. However, it requires regular monitoring and auditing to detect and correct any discrepancies or security issues.Security Best Practices
Following Microsoft’s best practices for deploying, configuring, and managing MIM is crucial for maintaining accuracy and security. This includes restricting access to sensitive data, implementing appropriate authentication and authorization controls, and regularly applying updates and patches.Limitations and Areas for Improvement
Despite its capabilities, MIM has several limitations and areas where it can be improved:Deprecated Features
Many features in MIM 2016 SP2 are deprecated and not recommended for new deployments. These features may be removed in future updates, which can impact long-term planning and compatibility.Lack of Advanced Features
MIM lacks certain advanced features that are available in newer identity management solutions. For example, it does not offer comprehensive reporting and auditing, passwordless authentication, compliance and governance tools, or access review and entitlement management.On-Premises Limitations
While MIM is strong in on-premises environments, it lacks some features that are available in cloud-based solutions like Azure AD. Specifically, it does not offer Role-Based Access Control (RBAC) for on-premises resources, Privileged Access Management (PAM) for on-premises AD DS environments, or comprehensive certificate management.Transition to Azure AD
Given the limitations and the fact that MIM is no longer actively developed by Microsoft, many organizations are considering transitioning to Azure AD. Azure AD offers a range of features that enhance identity and access management, including better reporting, auditing, and compliance tools. However, it also has its own set of limitations, particularly for on-premises environments, where some MIM features are still unmatched. In summary, while MIM remains a viable solution for identity and access management, its performance and accuracy are highly dependent on proper configuration and maintenance. However, its limitations and the deprecation of certain features make it essential to consider transitioning to more modern solutions like Azure AD for long-term security and compliance needs. Microsoft Identity Manager - Pricing and Plans
Current Status of MIM
MIM is currently in extended support until early 2029. This means that while it is still supported, it is not a new or actively developed product.
Pricing and Plans
There is no new licensing or pricing model specifically for MIM as a standalone product. Instead, users with certain Microsoft subscriptions can access MIM or its equivalent functionalities:
- Microsoft Entra ID Premium: Users with a Microsoft Entra ID Premium subscription can use MIM free of charge. This subscription includes a range of identity and access management features that overlap with or replace some of MIM’s capabilities.
Features and Alternatives
MIM’s core features include:
- User provisioning and deprovisioning
- Attribute synchronization
- Identity lifecycle management
- Business rule enforcement
- Directory synchronization
- Self-service and automation
- Access control and privilege management
- Certificate and key management
For new implementations or those looking to migrate, Microsoft recommends using their cloud-based identity management solutions, such as Microsoft Entra ID P1, P2, and the Entra Suite, which offer similar and enhanced features compared to MIM.
Free Options
There are no free standalone versions of MIM available for new users. However, existing users with a Microsoft Entra ID Premium subscription can continue to use MIM without additional costs.
In summary, while MIM itself does not have a new pricing structure, its functionalities are being integrated into Microsoft’s cloud-based identity management products, and users with the right subscriptions can access these features without extra cost.
Microsoft Identity Manager - Integration and Compatibility
Microsoft Identity Manager (MIM) 2016 Overview
MIM 2016 is a comprehensive identity and access management solution that integrates seamlessly with a variety of tools and platforms, ensuring consistent user identities across heterogeneous systems.Integration with Authoritative Systems
MIM 2016 bridges multiple on-premises authoritative systems and authentication stores, including Active Directory, SAP, Oracle, and other LDAP and SQL systems. It integrates with HR systems, directories, and databases, enabling automatic identity and group provisioning based on business policies and workflow-driven provisioning.Active Directory and Microsoft Entra ID
MIM works closely with Active Directory to ensure that the right users are provisioned for on-premises applications. It also integrates with Microsoft Entra ID, allowing these identities to be available for Microsoft 365 and cloud-hosted apps through Microsoft Entra Connect.Exchange and SharePoint
For mailbox provisioning and Global Address List (GAL) synchronization, MIM supports integration with Exchange Server 2016 and Exchange Server 2019. It also integrates with SharePoint Server 2016 and SharePoint Server 2019 for various collaborative and data management tasks.Database Compatibility
MIM supports several versions of SQL Server for its databases, including SQL Server 2016 SP3, SQL Server 2017, and SQL Server 2019. These databases are crucial for the MIM Sync, MIM Service, and MIM Certificate Management components.Operating System Compatibility
MIM 2016 can be deployed on various Windows Server versions, including Windows Server 2016, Windows Server 2019, and Windows Server 2022. However, older versions like Windows Server 2012 and Windows Server 2012 R2 are marked as “not recommended” for new deployments.Client and Browser Compatibility
For client-side operations, MIM supports Windows 10 and Windows 11. It also works with all major supported browsers, although mobile device support is limited. Additionally, MIM Add-ins and Extensions are compatible with Windows 10 and Windows 11.Outlook Integration
MIM integrates with Outlook 2016 (on Windows 10, except Click-To-Run) and Outlook for Microsoft 365 (on Windows 10, including Click-To-Run) for email-based workflows and approvals.Certificate Management
MIM Certificate Management supports integration with Windows Server 2012 R2, Windows Server 2016, and Windows Server 2019 for server and Certificate Authority (CA) integration. It also supports Windows 10 for client-side certificate management and uses Internet Explorer (IE) mode in Microsoft Edge 78 or later on Windows 11 for ActiveX-based smart card operations.Development Environment
For development purposes, MIM supports Visual Studio 2013, Visual Studio 2015, and Visual Studio 2017, allowing developers to create and customize MIM components and workflows.Zero Trust and Cloud Integration
While MIM 2016 is primarily an on-premises solution, it can be part of a broader identity management strategy that includes cloud-based services like Microsoft Entra ID. This integration enables secure authentication, authorization, and single sign-on (SSO) capabilities across both on-premises and cloud environments.Conclusion
In summary, Microsoft Identity Manager 2016 offers extensive integration capabilities with various systems, ensuring seamless identity management across different platforms and devices, making it a versatile tool for managing identities in a hybrid environment. Microsoft Identity Manager - Customer Support and Resources
Support Options for Microsoft Identity Manager (MIM)
Microsoft provides several support options and additional resources for customers using Microsoft Identity Manager to effectively manage and resolve issues.Azure Support
For Microsoft Entra ID P1 or P2 customers, you can open a support request through the Azure portal. Here’s how you can do it:Steps to Open a Support Request
- Select the issue type as “Technical”.
- Switch to show “All Services” and select “User Provisioning and Synchronization” under Microsoft Entra ID.
- Choose the problem type as “Microsoft Identity Manager (MIM)” and select the appropriate problem subtype such as “Connectors”, “Service and Portal”, or “Synchronization engine”.
Other Support Options
If you do not have an Azure support subscription or Microsoft Entra ID P1 or P2, you can still access support through other channels. For example, if you have Microsoft Professional Support, you can create a new support request by selecting the product family as “Security” and the product as “Identity Manager 2016”.Licensing and Downloads
For those needing to manage licenses, Microsoft Identity Manager 2016 requires specific licenses. You may need Client Access Licenses (CALs) for users whose identities are managed beyond synchronization, and Windows Server and SQL Server licenses are also necessary for the server software. You can download MIM 2016 SP2 from various sources, including the Visual Studio My Benefits Downloads for developer subscribers.Deployment and Configuration Resources
Microsoft provides detailed documentation for deploying and configuring MIM 2016. The deployment guide includes steps for preparing the domain, setting up identity management servers, and installing MIM components. This guide is particularly useful for end-user self-service scenarios and includes information on supported platforms and topologies for production deployments.Additional Resources
Microsoft also offers general support policies and lifecycle information. For instance, MIM 2016 SP2 was released in October 2019, and customers are encouraged to stay on the latest service pack for security and support reasons. The fixed lifecycle policy outlines specific dates for support lifecycle, which can be crucial for planning and maintenance. By leveraging these support options and resources, you can ensure that your Microsoft Identity Manager deployment is well-supported and efficiently managed. Microsoft Identity Manager - Pros and Cons
Advantages
Automation and Efficiency
MIM automates the provision, deprovision, and access management of users and groups across the enterprise, reducing the need for manual processes and ad-hoc user management scripts. This automation helps in ensuring compliance and streamlining identity lifecycle management.
Integration and Synchronization
MIM integrates well with heterogeneous platforms, including Active Directory and various business applications. It uses a rules-based synchronization engine to ensure that changes in source objects are replicated automatically to target platforms. This integration is further enhanced by Azure AD Connect, which synchronizes on-premises identities with Azure Active Directory.
Customization and Flexibility
MIM offers significant flexibility through its metaverse concept and connector spaces. Rules and extensions can be applied at various stages of the import, synchronization, and export processes, allowing for complete customization to meet specific identity management needs.
Comprehensive Components
MIM includes several components such as the MIM Synchronization Service, MIM Service, MIM Portal, Self Service Password Reset (SSPR) Web Portals, and MIM Reporting. These components provide a comprehensive solution for identity management, including privileged access management.
Disadvantages
Licensing and Cost
While MIM may be covered under certain Windows or Azure licenses, the overall cost of implementation and maintenance can still be significant. Organizations need to ensure they have the necessary licenses and budget for the components they require.
Complex Implementation
Although MIM offers great flexibility, its implementation can be complex. It requires careful configuration of rules and extensions, which can be time-consuming and may lead to overly complicated processes if not managed properly.
Need for Process Simplification
Implementing MIM is an opportunity to simplify existing identity management processes. However, if the existing processes are poorly documented or inefficient, MIM might only make these bad processes run faster rather than improving them.
On-Premises Focus
While MIM is highly effective for on-premises identity management, organizations that are transitioning to cloud-based solutions may need to consider how MIM fits into their long-term cloud strategy. MIM will continue to be supported, but there may be a need to plan for future cloud-based identity management solutions.
In summary, MIM is a powerful tool for automating and managing identities across various platforms, but it requires careful planning, configuration, and potentially significant resources.
Microsoft Identity Manager - Comparison with Competitors
When Comparing Microsoft Identity Manager (MIM) with Other IAM Products
Several key points and alternatives come into focus.Key Features of Microsoft Identity Manager
MIM is an on-premises IAM solution that offers a range of features, including:- Identity Management: User on- and offboarding, attribute synchronization, and self-service profile management.
- Group Management: Manual, manager-based, and dynamic groups with self-service workflows and access request & approval processes.
- Credential Management: Self-service functionalities, multi-factor authentication (MFA), and password synchronization.
- Policy Management: Authentication, authorization, codeless provisioning, and a SharePoint-based admin portal.
Unique Features
One of the unique aspects of MIM is its ability to synchronize identity data between various directories, databases, and applications. The MIM Synchronization Service uses a metaverse to consolidate and manage identity information from multiple sources, ensuring consistency and accuracy across different systems.Potential Alternatives
Azure Active Directory (Azure AD)
Azure AD is a cloud-based IAM solution that is often considered the closest replacement for MIM. It offers simple identity and access management for both internal and external users, with features like single sign-on, conditional access, and identity protection. Azure AD has a significant market share in the IAM category, with 22.50% market share, making it a strong alternative to MIM.Microsoft Active Directory (AD)
Microsoft Active Directory is another major competitor, with 20.47% market share. While it is primarily an on-premises solution, it can be integrated with Azure AD for a hybrid approach. It provides similar directory services but lacks some of the advanced cloud features of Azure AD.Auth0
Auth0 is a cloud-based IAM platform that offers a more flexible and scalable solution compared to MIM. It supports multiple authentication protocols, single sign-on, and multi-factor authentication. Auth0 has a 4.06% market share and is known for its ease of use and extensive customization options.AWS Identity and Access Management (IAM)
AWS IAM is a cloud-based service that enables you to manage access to AWS resources securely. It provides fine-grained access control, identity federation, and multi-factor authentication. With a 3.70% market share, AWS IAM is a strong alternative for organizations already invested in the AWS ecosystem.Market Share and Adoption
MIM has a relatively small market share of 0.35% in the IAM category, compared to its competitors. Despite this, it is still used by over 778 companies worldwide, including major organizations like Intesa Sanpaolo, JLR, and Chevron.Conclusion
While MIM offers comprehensive identity and access management features, its on-premises nature and limited market share make cloud-based alternatives like Azure AD and Auth0 more appealing for many organizations. Each of these alternatives has unique features and advantages, so the choice depends on the specific needs and infrastructure of the organization. Microsoft Identity Manager - Frequently Asked Questions
Frequently Asked Questions about Microsoft Identity Manager (MIM)
What is Microsoft Identity Manager (MIM)?
Microsoft Identity Manager (MIM) is a solution for managing identities and access across multiple systems. It centralizes the management of user accounts, groups, credentials, and policies, integrating with Active Directory and other external systems.What are the key features of Microsoft Identity Manager?
MIM includes several key features such as identity management (user on- and offboarding, attribute synchronization, self-service profile management), group management (manual, manager-based, and dynamic groups), credential management (self-service functionalities, multi-factor authentication, password synchronization), and policy management (authentication, authorization, codeless provisioning, and a SharePoint-based admin portal).How do I install Microsoft Identity Manager?
To install MIM, you need to follow specific pre-installation steps and then install the MIM Service and Portal components. After installation, you must verify that the MIM Portal is active and perform post-installation tasks such as configuring Internet Explorer settings and enabling non-administrators to access the MIM Portal.What happens to Microsoft Identity Manager now that it is approaching its end of life?
Microsoft Identity Manager is approaching its end of life, and the recommended replacement is Azure Active Directory (Azure AD). Azure AD offers a range of features for identity and access management, making it a suitable successor for MIM’s functionalities.How do I secure and harden my Microsoft Identity Manager deployment?
To secure and harden MIM, you should follow best practices provided by Microsoft. This includes restricting access to sensitive data and functions, implementing appropriate authentication and authorization controls, regularly updating and patching the system, configuring monitoring and logging, and developing effective backup and recovery strategies.Can I use Microsoft Identity Manager with other Microsoft products like SharePoint?
Yes, MIM can be integrated with other Microsoft products such as SharePoint. For example, MIM uses a SharePoint-based admin portal for policy management and other administrative tasks.What are the alternatives to Microsoft Identity Manager for identity and access management?
The primary alternative to MIM is Azure Active Directory (Azure AD), which offers comprehensive identity and access management features. Additionally, Microsoft Entra ID and other components of the Microsoft Entra suite can also serve as alternatives depending on the specific needs of your organization.How do I manage groups in Microsoft Identity Manager?
MIM allows for the management of manual, manager-based, and dynamic groups. It features self-service workflows and access request and approval processes, making it easier to manage group memberships and access.Can Microsoft Identity Manager handle credential management?
Yes, MIM includes credential management features such as self-service functionalities for password changes, resets, and unlocks, as well as multi-factor authentication and password synchronization.How do I ensure compliance and policy management with Microsoft Identity Manager?
MIM provides policy management features that cover authentication, authorization, codeless provisioning, and more. It also includes a SharePoint-based admin portal to manage these policies effectively.What are the post-installation tasks for Microsoft Identity Manager?
After installing MIM, you need to verify that the MIM Portal is active, configure Internet Explorer settings, enable non-administrators to access the MIM Portal, and optionally install MIM add-ins and extensions. Microsoft Identity Manager - Conclusion and Recommendation
Final Assessment of Microsoft Identity Manager (MIM)
Microsoft Identity Manager (MIM) is a comprehensive identity and access management solution, particularly suited for organizations with significant on-premises infrastructure. Here’s a detailed assessment of who would benefit most from using MIM and an overall recommendation.Key Features and Benefits
MIM is adept at simplifying identity lifecycle management through automated workflows, business rules, and integration with heterogeneous platforms. It includes features such as:- Identity management: User on- and offboarding, attribute synchronization, and self-service profile management.
- Group management: Manual, manager-based, and dynamic groups with self-service workflows and access request & approval processes.
- Credential management: Self-service functionalities, Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA), and password synchronization.
- Policy management: Authentication, authorization, codeless provisioning, and a SharePoint-based admin portal.
Who Would Benefit Most
MIM is ideal for large organizations, especially those with 10,000 employees, as it is commonly used in such environments. Companies like Intesa Sanpaolo, Chevron, Huawei Technologies, and General Electric, which have extensive on-premises infrastructure, can significantly benefit from MIM’s capabilities. Organizations that are not yet fully transitioned to cloud-based solutions but need to manage both on-premises and cloud identities will also find MIM valuable. It integrates well with Azure AD Connect, allowing the synchronization of identity information between on-premises systems and Azure Active Directory for use with Microsoft 365 and other cloud-hosted applications.Limitations and Future Considerations
While MIM is a powerful tool, it has some limitations. It lacks certain functionalities such as reporting and auditing, passwordless authentication, compliance and governance tools, and access review and entitlement management. These gaps can be addressed by integrating third-party tools or transitioning to cloud-based solutions like Azure Active Directory (Azure AD). Given that MIM is being decommissioned and the industry is moving towards cloud-first or hybrid environments, it is recommended to start planning for a transition to Azure AD. Azure AD offers a range of features that enhance identity and access management, including better reporting, auditing, and compliance tools.Recommendation
For organizations currently using MIM, it is advisable to assess their long-term identity management strategy. Here are some steps to consider:- Evaluate Cloud Transition: If your organization is moving towards a cloud-first or hybrid environment, consider transitioning to Azure AD, which offers more comprehensive features and better integration with cloud services.
- Integrate Third-Party Tools: To fill the gaps in MIM’s functionality, integrate third-party tools like Omada Identity to add essential identity governance functionalities such as onboarding, transfer, offboarding, and access requests.
- Plan for Decommissioning: Since MIM is being decommissioned, start planning the migration process to avoid any disruptions in identity management services.